Guide

HEI vs HEA vs shared equity agreement: what's the difference?

Providers use different names for the same basic product. The names don't change what you pay. The structure does.

The short answer

A home equity investment (HEI), a home equity agreement (HEA), and a shared equity agreement are mostly different names for the same kind of product: cash now, no monthly payments, and a share of your home's value later.

What actually changes your cost is the structure: whether the provider takes a share of your home's gain or its whole value, the multiplier, the starting value, the cost cap, and the term.

What each provider calls it

And how each one actually works.

ProviderWhat they call itHow you repay
PointHome Equity Investment (HEI)Share of your home's gain, measured from a starting value set below your appraisal
HometapHome Equity InvestmentShare of your home's total value at settlement
UnlockHome Equity Agreement (HEA)Share of your home's future value, set with an exchange rate
UnisonEquity Sharing AgreementShare of your home's change in value, up or down
SpliteroHome Equity InvestmentShare of your home's appreciation (share not published)
CHEIFSHome equity investment agreementShare of your home's future value (share not published)

Why the names differ

Each provider picked its own label. "Investment" emphasizes that the company is buying a stake in your home, not lending you money. "Agreement" emphasizes the contract. Regulators often use a broader term, home equity contract, to cover all of them.

The differences that matter

  • Share of gain vs share of value. Some providers take a share of how much your home gains; others take a share of its whole value at settlement. Share-of-value agreements cost you money even if your home doesn't appreciate.
  • The multiplier. Your share is usually a multiple of what you received: 1.65 to 2 times for share-of-value providers, and 2.4 to 4 times for share-of-gain providers, in published examples.
  • The starting value. Share-of-gain providers may measure gain from a value set below your appraisal, from 5% to 27% below in published terms.
  • The cost cap. Published caps range from about 13% to 20% a year, and some providers publish none.
  • The term. Some agreements must be settled within 10 years; others allow up to 30.

Because of these differences, the same cash can cost very different amounts. In our standard example ($100,000 against a $750,000 home with a $300,000 mortgage, 4% growth, 7 years), costs range from 14.1% to 15.9% a year across the providers we can model. See them side by side.

Other names you'll see

Shared appreciation agreement, home equity sharing agreement, equity sharing agreement, and home equity contract all describe the same family of products. When you're comparing offers, ignore the label and compare the effective annual cost.

Questions

Is a home equity agreement (HEA) a loan?

Providers structure HEAs and HEIs as an investment in your home rather than a loan: there's no interest and no monthly payment. Some regulators have questioned how these products should be treated, so read your agreement closely.

Is Unison's equity sharing agreement an HEI?

Yes, in everything but name. Unison shares in your home's change in value, up or down, in exchange for cash now, just like other home equity investments.

What is a home equity contract?

It's the umbrella term regulators use for home equity investments, home equity agreements, and shared equity agreements.

Run your own numbers

Every figure here uses a standard example. The calculator runs your home, your mortgage, and your assumptions through every provider at once.

Open the HEI CalculatorGet a free offer review

HEI Compare and HEI Calculator are sister sites run by the same independent team. Both use the same provider terms and the same cost model. About us.