The short answer
On cost, they are close. In our standard example ($100,000 against a $750,000 home with a $300,000 mortgage, 4% growth, settled after 7 years), Hometap costs 14.1% a year and Point 14.4%.
The real differences are time and growth. Point gives you up to 30 years; Hometap gives you 10. Point costs less if your home's value barely moves. Hometap costs less once your home grows about 3.2% a year or more.
Which fits you
- You need more than 10 years: Point. Hometap has to be settled by year 10.
- Your home may not gain much: Point (8.4% a year vs 9.7% with no growth over 7 years).
- You expect steady growth and will hold 7 to 10 years: Hometap (16.3% vs 17.3% at 6% growth over 7 years).
- You plan to settle around year 5: Hometap (16.4% vs 18.3% at 4% growth). Its smaller share applies through year 5.
- You may settle within 3 years: about the same, and expensive with either. Both reach their limit (22.2% for Point, 22.7% for Hometap).
- You need a larger share of your home's value: Hometap, up to 27% against Point's 20%.
- Your credit score is between 500 and 574: Point. Hometap starts at 575.
What you'd pay back, in dollars
The same example for both: $100,000 against a $750,000 home with a $300,000 mortgage. After fees and closing costs you receive about $93,600 from Point and $94,000 from Hometap.
| Your home grows | After 5 years | After 7 years | After 10 years | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Point | Hometap | Point | Hometap | Point | Hometap | |
| No growth | $164,800 | $165,000 | $164,800 | $180,000 | $164,800 | $180,000 |
| 2% a year | $189,779 | $182,173 | $200,485 | $206,763 | $217,359 | $219,419 |
| 4% a year | $216,797 | $200,748 | $240,624 | $236,868 | $280,059 | $266,444 |
| 6% a year | $244,322 | $220,807 | $285,671 | $270,653 | $354,603 | $322,353 |
| 8% a year | $244,322 | $242,439 | $336,118 | $308,488 | $442,942 | $388,606 |
The lower of each pair is highlighted. One payment, made when you sell, refinance or buy the company out.
See the same table as a yearly costEffective annual cost, including 3 years
| Your home grows | 3 years | 5 years | 7 years | 10 years | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Point | Hometap | Point | Hometap | Point | Hometap | Point | Hometap | |
| No growth | 20.8% | 20.6% | 12.0% | 11.9% | 8.4% | 9.7% | 5.8% | 6.7% |
| 2% a year | 22.2% | 22.7% | 15.2% | 14.1% | 11.5% | 11.9% | 8.8% | 8.8% |
| 4% a year | 22.2% | 22.7% | 18.3% | 16.4% | 14.4% | 14.1% | 11.6% | 11.0% |
| 6% a year | 22.2% | 22.7% | 21.2% | 18.6% | 17.3% | 16.3% | 14.2% | 13.1% |
| 8% a year | 22.2% | 22.7% | 21.2% | 20.9% | 20.0% | 18.5% | 16.8% | 15.2% |
Yearly cost is measured on the cash you actually receive, after the provider's fee and about $1,500 of closing costs. Measured on the full investment instead, it's lower: in our standard example ($100,000 on a $750,000 home, 4% yearly growth, 7 years), Hometap is 13.1% a year instead of 14.1%.
Side by side
| Term | Point | Hometap |
|---|---|---|
| What they take | A share of your home's gain, measured from a starting value set below your appraisal (27% below in Point's own example) | A share of your home's total value on the day you settle |
| Their share, for 10% of your home's value | 24% of the gain | 16.5% of the value if you settle in years 1 to 5, then 18% |
| Time to settle | Up to 30 years | 10 years |
| Limit on their return | Yes, but Point does not publish the rate. We use 18% a year | 18.5% a year, compounded monthly |
| Fee | Up to 4.9%, with a $2,000 minimum | 4.5%, up to $20,000 |
| Cash you can get | $30,000 to $600,000 | $15,000 to $600,000 |
| Most of your home's value you can take | 20% | 27% |
| Equity rule | At least 25% equity before the investment | Your mortgage plus the investment can't pass 75% of your home's value |
| Lowest credit score | 500 | 575 |
| Second homes and rentals | Yes, on terms Point does not publish | Yes |
| Where | 31 states and Washington, DC | 27 states |
Why the same home gives different answers
Point takes a share of the gain
Point sets a starting value below your appraisal. In its own example the starting value is 27% lower.
It then takes a share of everything above that line: 24% of it, for 10% of your home's value. So Point is owed something even if your home's price never rises, because the line starts under today's value.
If your home is flat, that built-in amount is all you owe on top of the original cash. That is why Point is the cheaper one when growth is low.
Hometap takes a share of the whole home
Hometap takes a set percentage of whatever your home is worth on the day you settle. For 10% of your home's value, that is 16.5% in the first five years and 18% after.
With no growth you still owe more than you received, because the percentage is larger than what was invested.
Each extra dollar of growth adds 18 cents to what you owe Hometap and 24 cents to what you owe Point. That is why Hometap is the cheaper one when growth is steady.
Held for 7 years, the two lines cross at about 3.2% growth a year. Held for 10, they cross at about 2.2%.
Ask both before you sign
Point sets its share for each offer and does not publish the rate of its limit. Hometap's share depends on how much you take. So the page you sign matters more than any example, including ours.
- Point: What is my starting value, and what share of the gain do you take?
- Point: What yearly rate is my Homeowner Protection Cap?
- Hometap: What share applies in years 1 to 5, and in years 6 to 10, for my amount?
- Both: What is the fee in dollars, and what other closing costs come out of my cash?
- Both: What would I owe if I settle in year 3, 7 and 10, with no growth and with 4% growth?
Where each one works
Point works in 31 states and Washington, DC. Hometap works in 27 states. Both work in 21 of the same states.
- Point only: Colorado, Connecticut, District of Columbia, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Minnesota, Mississippi and Washington.
- Hometap only: Alabama, Delaware, Idaho, Montana, New Hampshire and New Mexico.
Both companies say availability can vary by county.
Questions
Is Point or Hometap cheaper?
It depends on how long you keep it and how much your home grows. In our example, settled after 7 years, Point costs less if your home grows less than about 3.2% a year and Hometap costs less above that. At 4% growth the two are close: Hometap 14.1% a year, Point 14.4%.
Which one gives you more cash?
Hometap, for most homes. It will invest up to 27% of your home's value and Point up to 20%. Both stop at $600,000. Point's smallest investment is $30,000 and Hometap's is $15,000.
Which is easier to qualify for?
Point accepts credit scores from 500 and Hometap from 575. Point asks for at least 25% equity before it invests. Hometap looks at the total: your mortgage plus its investment can't pass 75% of your home's value.
What happens when the time runs out?
You have to settle: sell, refinance, or pay the company from savings or another loan. Hometap gives you 10 years and Point up to 30. A short term can force that decision in a year when rates or prices are against you.
Do Point and Hometap work with rentals and second homes?
Both do. Hometap says it invests in vacation and rental properties. Point says investment properties and second homes are eligible, on criteria it does not publish.
Sources
- Point: how the HEI works
- Point: worked example
- Point: states
- Hometap: how pricing works
- Hometap: FAQs
Comparing two other companies? Pick any pair.
Offer reviews
Do you have an offer you'd like us to help you with? Contact us